Biblical Inerrancy 2.0

By -

THE TENSION OF BIBLICAL INERRANCY | AN “IN-HOUSE” DEBATE
I have believed my entire life that the Bible is inspired by God, infallible (true in all it teaches), and inerrant (totally free from all errors).  Recently, I have begun to think critically about this belief.  I have not abandoned it by any means, but rather have to ask the question, “Why should I believe this?”

Recently I’ve done a lot of thinking on this subject.  A friend of mine is attending Pittsburg Theological Seminary, where a majority of professors do not hold to inerrancy, infallibility and even inerrancy.  It’s caused him (and vicariously through him, me) to ask, “Why preach from it?”  “What’s the point?” “What separates this book from any other?”

For more of my thoughts, see my previous blog post here:
http://thewaymattseesit.blogspot.com/2014/10/my-thoughts-on-biblical-inerrancy.html

I would like to reiterate that Biblical inspiration/infallibility/inerrancy is not a prerequisite for faith in Jesus.  Nor would this issue invalidate the truth of Christianity.  For this reason, this issue can be considered an “in-house” debate among Christians.


JESUS’ VIEW OF SCRIPTURE
As Christians, our impulse should be to turn to Jesus.
Jesus himself viewed the Bible as inspired by God.  He demonstrated a clear knowledge of the authors of Old Testament passages, but credited God with writing the passage.  He knew that the Holy Spirit had inspired the biblical authors.  Jesus responded, “Then why does David, speaking under the inspiration of the Spirit, call the Messiah ‘my Lord’?” (Matthew 22:43).

Jesus also viewed the Bible as infallible (true in all it teaches).  He believed that he was the fulfillment of scripture, using a passage in Isaiah as an initiation to his ministry (Luke 4:16-21).  He also used scripture to overcome temptation against Satan, demonstrating that he assumed its truth (Luke 4:4, 8, 12).  Jesus further asserted that, “not the smallest letter, not the least stroke of the pen,” will disappear until scripture was fulfilled, further demonstrating his view of infallibility (Matthew 5:18).


THE CHRISTIAN’S CONCLUSION
Clearly, we see Jesus believed in inspiration and infallibility.  I feel that inerrancy is harder to defend, but perhaps Matthew 5:18 could also be used to defend inerrancy.  He believed that not the smallest letter would pass away; that seems to go beyond infallibility (true in all it teaches), even stretching to inerrancy (totally free from all errors).  I’m not sure if I can say this is too large of a jump or not.

As Christians, I believe we must at least commit ourselves to the inspiration and infallibility of scripture.  Even if [minor] errors were to surface in the Bible (factual, historical, etc.) it would not invalidate the inspiration and infallibility of scripture.  If Jesus held to this view, then as followers of Jesus, Christians should hold to this view as well.

 Being that Jesus viewed the Bible as inspired and infallible, then as followers of Christ, Christians should view the Bible as inspired and infallible.



STILL WORKING THROUGH
Finally, I am still working out how this should apply to the New Testament.  Being extremely nitpicky, Jesus’ view of scripture only applies to the Old Testament (the NT hadn’t been written yet).  A different case would have to be made for this.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

LOTR On Prime: Timeline of The Second Age

By -
Image
THE PURPOSE OF THIS INFOGRAPHIC With Amazon's new show in the works, tentatively titled, "LOTR On Prime", you might be wondering what the show will be about. What content is available for them to use? Where are they getting this from? Will characters from the Lord of the Rings films be in it? This timeline was created to answer and visualize many of these questions, designed with the casual fan in mind. It is an infographic illustrating almost everything that takes place in The Second Age, which is when the show will take place (we say "almost" because, inevitably, there's always something else that could be included). WHAT IF I ONLY KNOW THE MOVIES? The Lord of the Rings takes place during the Third Age of the world. While this is certainly the most iconic story that J.R.R. Tolkien ever wrote, he also built an extensive world beyond that of The War of the Ring. The Amazon Prime show will take place primarily during The Second Age, which many events go on t
Read more

WHO IS THE BEST BATMAN?

By -
Image
I’m talking about the best live-action film version of Batman.   If we had to go to the greatest portrayal of Batman across all forms of media, hands down it would be Kevin Conroy as Batman in the Arkham games.   I firmly believe this series (specifically Batman: Arkham Asylum and Batman: Arkham City) are the absolutely the best version of Batman, his villains, and the overall mythos. As far as live-action films, it’s clearly between three actors: Michael Keaton, Christian Bale, and Ben Affleck.   While they all have pros and cons to their performances, here’s what I think they are each able to do really well: MICHAEL KEATON No matter how you might feel about Michael Keaton’s performance, no one can argue that it defined how Batman would be portrayed for decades to come.   Before this, Batman was campy and not taken seriously.   When I look back and watch this late 80’s movie, I’m not particularly impressed (being born a few years after its theatrical release), but
Read more

What Is Speaking In Tongues?

By -
Image
SPEAKING IN TONGUES This can be a touchy subject among Christians.   There are varying viewpoints, and this issue seems to spark so much emotional and personal feelings it’s almost taboo to talk about it even among Christian circles.   I’ve decided to focus on answering 10 questions regarding speaking in tongues.             1. What is speaking in tongues?             2. Is speaking in tongues found in the Bible?             3. What is Baptism in the Holy Spirit?             4. Why is there so much division on this subject?             5. Is speaking in tongues still for today, or was that just for the Early Church?             6. Who can speak in tongues?             7. Is the “initial physical evidence” really that important?             8. Do you lose control of yourself when you speak in tongues?             9. Am I not saved / less of a Christian if I don’t speak in tongues?             10. If I’ve prayed for this gift, why haven’t I received it?
Read more